A Gooey Cookie at Leena’s Cookies

Leena's Cookies
Location
: 14 Irwin Avenue, Toronto
Website: https://www.instagram.com/leenas_cookies/

I’ve mentioned before that I’m not crazy about the current Crumbl-inspired trend of big, underbaked chocolate chip cookies.  Slightly underbaked?  Sure!  A soft, chewy cookie is where it’s at.

When you underbake a cookie too much, however, the texture is more mushy than chewy.  And the flavour of mostly raw, undercooked flour is unmistakable.  Uncooked cookie dough is tasty, and so is a fully baked cookie — but in the middle is a no man’s land that doesn’t entirely embrace the pleasures of either.

Leena's Cookies

All this is to say that they underbake the cookies at Leena’s way too much — but it’s still tasty.  If you’re into this style of cookie, it doesn’t get much better.  Certainly, it’s way, way (way way way) better than Crumbl, whose popularity is absolutely mystifying to me.

The woman behind the counter mentioned that the salted caramel is the most popular choice, and yeah, I get it: it’s got a generous amount of good quality chocolate chips, and is absolutely crammed with gooey salted caramel.  As soon as I broke it in half, the caramel started leaking out.  It’s impressive that the cookie manages to even hold together.

Leena's Cookies

And yet despite all that caramel and chocolate, it’s not too sweet; the caramel has a deep, rich flavour that helps to cut through the sweetness, not to mention the mild hit of salt.

The cookie itself is nice and buttery (it left translucent stains on the paper bag almost immediately — always a good sign for a pastry), but doesn’t taste overly greasy, and it has a mild crispiness on its exterior that (somewhat) helps to balance out how soft it is.

Leena's Cookies

If it were fully baked, it’d probably be up there with the best cookies in the city.  But even as is, given the quality, I have no doubt it’ll have its fans.

Leave a Reply