Tasty Cake Doughnuts at Maverick’s Donut Company

Maverick's Donut Company
Location
: 1618 Queen Street West, Toronto
Website: https://mavericksdonuts.com/

Maverick’s is an Ottawa-based doughnut chain that opened their first location in Toronto last year.  You might be thinking that we have enough doughnut joints in the city, but you’re wrong and here’s why: Maverick’s specializes in cake-based doughnuts.  Most doughnut places will have a cake doughnut or two on the menu, but here it’s pretty much all of them.

Maverick's Donut Company

I tried six: cherry glazed, pecan pie, maple bacon, double chocolate, lemon ricotta, and chocolate coconut.

They were all quite delightful.  The cake is dense but not too dense, they’re not overly sweet (aside from maybe the maple bacon, which I still quite enjoyed), and they have a light crispiness on their exterior.  They’re top quality doughnuts.

Maverick's Donut Company

And the flavours were all great, though if I had to pick a favourite, it might be the nutty pecan pie.  Or the double chocolate, which had a really satisfying chocolate flavour.  Or the cherry glazed, which tasted like a doughnut and a maraschino cherry had a baby.  Or the lemon ricotta, which had a nice tartness and a satisfying creaminess.  Or the maple bacon, which had satisfying pops of saltiness from the bacon to offset the sweetness of the maple.  Or the chocolate coconut, which is always a tasty combo.

Oh, I just named all the doughnuts, didn’t I.  Well you know what?  I liked all of them.  They’re all my favourite.  Deal with it.

Delicious Butter Tarts at Circles and Squares

Circles and Squares
Location
: 197 Bartley Drive, North York
Website: https://www.circlesandsquares.ca/

After hearing that Circles and Squares had been awarded first prize at Ontario’s Best Butter Tart Festival last year, my first thought was — wait, there’s a butter tart festival?  My second thought was that I’ve gotta try those tarts.

Circles and Squares actually won two awards: first place in the best traditional butter tart category, and second place in the best “wild-style” butter tart category (for their Snickers butter tart, which features chocolate and peanut butter).

Circles and Squares

I tried the traditional butter tart both with and without pecans, the Snickers butter tart, and the double chocolate butter tart.

They were all very good, but the traditional ones were the clear winners.  I can see why they won first place — they’re gooey but not too gooey, the flavour is rich and sweet without being cloying, and the crust is fantastic.  It’s a top notch butter tart.

Circles and Squares

The other two were tasty, but all the stuff took away from their butter tartiness.  They tasted more like little chocolate pies that were slightly too sweet.  They were still delicious, mind you, but they couldn’t help but be a bit disappointing next to the amazing traditional tarts.

Apple Fritter Greatness at Better Days Coffee & Donuts

Better Days Coffee & Donuts
Location
: 963 Dovercourt Road, Toronto
Website: https://www.betterdaysdonuts.ca/

Better Days Coffee & Donuts is a delightful new doughnut shop on Dovercourt, and you know what?  I’m not going to beat around the bush.  The apple fritter here is the best I’ve ever had.

Better Days Coffee & Donuts

Better Days is inspired by the classics, with the owner telling Toronto Life that they won’t have any “stunt doughnuts” (i.e. social-media-friendly creations with elaborate toppings) on the menu.  I enjoy a good stunt doughnut every now and then, but you can’t beat the classics.

Better Days Coffee & Donuts

And it doesn’t get more classic than an apple fritter, which is unbelievably good here.  Again: it’s the best apple fritter I’ve ever had.

Better Days Coffee & Donuts

It’s just the perfect combo of a crispy/craggly exterior and a moist interior with enjoyably tender apple chunks interspersed throughout.  It covered in a sweet glaze, but it’s never cloying, with a delicious balance of sweetness that feels just right.  I could eat about a million of these.  Strap me down into one of those Homer Simpson doughnut force-feeding machines, please.

Better Days Coffee & Donuts

I also tried the double chocolate, which was a delicious cake doughnut with a satisfying chocolatey punch.  Nothing can compare to that glorious fritter, but it’s still clearly above average.

A Delicious Almond Croissant at Castle and Coal

Castle and Coal
Location
: 108 Dovercourt Road, Toronto
Website: https://castleandcoal.ca/

I have a hard time saying no to an almond croissant.  There’s something about the combo of a crispy, fluffy, buttery croissant with the creamy, sweet almond paste that’s kind of magical.

Castle and Coal

The version of Castle and Coal also has chocolate in it (it’s basically a cross between a traditional almond croissant and a pain au chocolate), and sure, why not?  Add chocolate to every dessert.  I have a hard time thinking of a dessert that wouldn’t be enhanced by adding chocolate.

Castle and Coal

The croissant itself doesn’t quite have the level of exterior crispiness that you’re hoping for, but it’s otherwise right where you want it to be.  The very generous amount of almond paste almost borders on too sweet, but never crosses that line (and the addition of dark chocolate, aside from complementing it quite well, does a good job of balancing out the sweetness of the filling).

Quick Bites: Chica’s Chicken, SumiLicious, Honey’s

The O.G. Sandwich from Chica's Chicken
The O.G. Sandwich from Chica’s Chicken

The Nashville hot chicken sandwich at Chica’s is very different than it used to be.  I should note that it’s still juicy, crispy, and abundantly flavourful.  It’s easily one of the best fried chicken sandwiches in the city.  But it used to be among the best fried chicken I’ve ever had, and it’s not quite there at the moment.  It’s also noticeably smaller than it used to be — I’m going to guess that it’s about one third of the size?  If you look at a photo of what it used to look like, and then compare it to the photo above, the difference is stark.  Chica’s used to sell a smaller sandwich called the “Small Fry,” which they clearly got rid of because it is not possible to sell a sandwich smaller than what they’re currently serving.  I also ordered it at the max level of heat, “hot AF,” and while it was quite spicy, it’s not at the blow-your-head-off level of heat that it used to be.  Still!  I need to reiterate that it’s very, very good.  A step down from the best fried chicken I’ve ever had is still pretty damn good.

SumiLicious
Smoked meat sandwich at SumiLicious

I haven’t been back to SumiLicious since it opened in 2018; it’s since been recognized by no less than the Michelin guide, and I was curious to see how it’s held up.  Well, it was glorious then, and it’s just as glorious now.  I mean, just look at the photo.  Look at it.  It’s easily the best smoked meat in the city.  I actually had Schwartz’s in Montreal relatively recently, and while I think that place is still the king (the spicing there is a bit more satisfying), SumiLicious is pretty close.

Honey's
Chocolate matzo toffee crunch ice cream from Honey’s

I’ve written about Honey’s before, and how shocked I was that a place that serves entirely vegan scoops of ice cream could be so thoroughly delicious.  Well, it’s still mystifyingly good.  Seriously, how can vegan ice cream be this creamy??  I will say that the more you eat it, the more you notice the absence of the expected dairy/creamy flavour, but aside from that, the texture and flavour is dead on.  I’m pretty positive that if you went out and did a blind taste test, 99 percent of people would have no idea that what they’re serving here is vegan.  As for this particular flavour, it was quite good — the matzo has a mild crunch from the toffee, and a nice restrained sweetness that works very well with the chocolate.